New Blog

Check out distinctlychristianthinking.blogspot.com

I'll be moving several blog posts over there and I will continue to update that site more than this current one.

The Article

Saturday, November 29, 2008

Progress of Theology in America: Conclusions

Introductory Posting

Here is a brief summary of each of the writers we have looked at followed by a short conclusion that can be drawn from noticing the progression of theology in America:

John Winthrop (1588-1649), A Model of Christian Charity. The settlers of the Massachusetts Bay Colony were in a unique covenantal relationship with God, very similar to that of ancient Israel (having fled from their oppressors, across the water, and into the land)...while there are similarities between their calling to a new land and Israel’s calling, the settlers of Massachusetts Bay were still distinct – distinctly American. They are not an extension of Israel, but a replacement of it in relationship with God.

Thomas Hooker (1586-1647), The Activity of Faith: or, Abraham’s Imitators. There are Christians deeply rooted in the church, who are unredeemed. Faith cannot be inherited from the previous generation simply by following the routines they have set forth for the society. The new generation believes that their acts are enough to warrant the favor of God. They hope in their baptisms, their church attendance, hearing the Word, or receiving the sacraments. They live in ignorance believing that these will bring salvation… utterly surprised to hear that they won’t. “A faithful man is a fruitful man.” ...believers are then called to follow in the footsteps of Abraham’s faith, not his circumcision.

Jonathan Edwards (1703-1758), Personal Narrative. God has produced a great change at the point of conversion. The believer now has a sense of God’s glory and majesty. More and more they come to an inward sense of sweetness, seeing His glory in everything. The believer now fixes his mind God. What was so terrible before is now so sweet. As Edwards states “My experience had not the taught me, as it has done since…the bottomless depths of secret corruption and deceit there was in my heart.” This is original sin. This is the sin nature of humanity. But miraculously there comes a change from the hand of God. Now the believer has a much greater sense of God’s grace. The believer has an abhorrence of his own righteousness. The soul of the Christian receives grace from God and in turn emits the sweet aroma of the Lord. God is now seen as who He is and loved for it.

David Walker (1785-1830), Our Wretchedness in Consequence of the Preachers of the Religion of Jesus Christ. ...the pure religion that was taught by Jesus Christ is scarce to be found. God gave a dispensation of his will to Israel who proceeded to depart from faith through hypocrisy and oppression. He then gave a dispensation to the Europeans, “together with the will of Jesus.” The Europeans are now in violation for having made the African into a piece of merchandise, and even using religion to aid them in the oppressive process. The city on a hill is no longer lovely to behold, but it is now wretched and despised...Christians beat the Africans for praying to the God that created them. Destruction will come to America for breaking its covenantal relationship with God through its social injustices. “Oh Americans! Americans!! I warn you in the name of the Lord to repent and reform, or you are ruined!!!”

William Ellery Channing (1780-1842), The Essence of Christian Religion. There is one great, central truth and principle of Christianity – God purposes to perfect the human soul. God purposes the elevation of men to a diviner being. The religion of Jesus Christ is a religion suited to fulfill the wants of every human being. Man is capable of great things. No longer should he be mired under the weight of original sin as it is not befitting of the rational person.

Charles Grandison Finney (1792-1875), Lectures on Revivals of Religion. Calculated planning is essential in order to influence rational people toward God. “Religion is the work of man.” ...all the religion in the world has been produced by revivals. Believers must be rationally appealed to, often in a way so outrageous as to wear them down and break through any barriers they had constructed to the gospel. “A revival of religion is not a miracle…It is a purely philosophical result of the right use of the constituted means.” It is man’s job to go to work promoting religion, not just sit back and rely on God’s sovereignty.

Sarah M. Grimké (1792-1873), Letters on the Equality of the Sexes and the Condition of Women. In looking at Genesis, man and woman were clearly created in equality. They are given dominion over the earth and over the animals, yet they are not given dominion over each other. God created us equal and created us as free agents. To God alone, and to no one else, is woman bound in subjection. “All I ask of our brethren is that they will take their feet from off our necks and permit us to stand upright on the ground which God designed us to occupy.”

Ralph Waldo Emerson (1803-1882), The Divinity School Address. There is much optimism about the human nature. Individuals must find the truth within themselves and not from second hand sources. Respect the perfection of this world, though not as something displaying the sovereignty of God, but rather as perfection in and of itself. Man is the greatest good. Humans should go at life alone. Love God purely, without a mediator or a veil, such as tradition or the Bible.

Mary Baker Eddy (1821-1910), Science and Health with Key to the Scriptures. The might of truth is in the treatment of disease as well as sin. The discords of the corporeal sense must yield to the harmony of the spiritual sense. The spirit is good and real. Matter, the physical world, is spirit’s opposite. “Christian science rationally explains that all other pathological methods are the fruits of human faith in matter, - faith in the workings, not of the spirit, but of the fleshly mind which must yield to science.” Science is god.

Joseph Smith (1805-1844), King Follett Discourse. God himself was once as we are. That is the great secret. If you could see God right now, he would appear as a man. “Here is eternal life – to know the only wise and true God; and you have got to learn how to be gods yourselves, and to be kings and priests to God, the same as all gods have done before you.” God is just like you and me. He is nothing extraordinary. Everyone can be god.

Horace Bushnell (1802-1876), Christian Nurture. A child is to grow up Christian and never know himself as being otherwise. ...there is a moral incongruity to say to a child that he will reject God and holy principle until he comes to a mature age. In reality, the expectation of the parent will become the expectation of the child. If the expectation is that the child will reject God, then he will. We seem to fancy that there is some moment in which the child becomes a moral agent. Perhaps character is built rather from the environment around a person rather than instilled within them by God at the point of conversion. Our character is determined by our natural environment, not by a supernatural experience.


Conclusions


Many of these writers shared, in very different ways,
Winthrop’s vision of the United States as a special, city on a hill. But the injustices of American society, from slavery to the treatment of women, raised questions about that ideal and that teaching. Other questions arose leading to the denial of the Trinity, the exaltation of reason and science, and a complete departure from original sin. These writings portray a religion being very much tossed about on the waves of a cultural enlightenment and an increased optimism in the natural ability of human kind. There needs to be a return to some of the concepts present in those first writings. We are to be a city on a hill (but as believers, not as Americans). We are to be a guiding light for a confused culture around us. Rather than being washed out to sea by the waves, we should stand firm on the solid rock of Christ, the gospel, and the scriptures. We are a lighthouse, guiding people home.

No comments: