New Blog

Check out distinctlychristianthinking.blogspot.com

I'll be moving several blog posts over there and I will continue to update that site more than this current one.

The Article

Friday, November 28, 2008

Progress of Theology in America: Horace Bushnell

Introductory Posting

Horace Bushnell (1802-1876),
Christian Nurture
.

Bushnell, a Congregational minister in Hartford, Connecticut, tried to find creative theological alternatives to strict orthodoxy on the one hand and liberalism shading into Unitarianism on the other. He had original things to say about the nature of religious language and the work of Christ. Christian Nurture, probably his most influential book, defended the growing Sunday school movement against revivalists unfriendly to the idea of gradual growth in faith from early childhood. In his criticisms of individualism and his use of organic metaphors, Bushnell shows the influence of Romantic ideas that he, like Emerson, was getting from Europe (p. 126-127).

A child is to grow up Christian and never know himself as being otherwise. The aim should not be individualistic, that the child grows up in sin, to be converted after he comes to a mature age; but that he is to open on the world as one that is spiritually renewed, not remembering when he went through a technical experience. The argument for this is that there is no absurdity in supposing that children are to grow up in Christ. In fact, there is a moral incongruity to say to a child that he will reject God and holy principle until he comes to a mature age. In reality, the expectation of the parent will become the expectation of the child. If the expectation is that the child will reject God, then he will. “The tendency of all our modern speculations is to an extreme individualism, and we carry our doctrines of free will so far as to make little or nothing of organic laws.” We seem to ignore the organic connection to character. We seem to fancy that there is some moment in which the child becomes a moral agent. Perhaps character is built rather from the environment around a person rather than instilled within them by God at the point of conversion. This is the very idea of Christian education. It begins with nurture. The spirit of the parents shall flow into the mind of the child and beget their own good within him. All Christian parents would like to see their children grow up in piety – the better Christians they are the more they desire it. A pure, separate, individual man, living wholly within, and from himself, is a mere fiction. “All society is organic – the church, state, school, family. And there is spirit within each of these organisms, peculiar to itself, and more or less hostile, more or less favorable to religious character, and to some extent, sovereign over the individual man.” Our character is determined by our natural environment, not by a supernatural experience.

Tomorrow: Conclusions

No comments: